Explore the various UI frameworks available for building app interfaces. Discuss the use cases for different frameworks, share best practices, and get help with specific framework-related questions.

All subtopics
Posts under UI Frameworks topic

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Trigger save of a FileDocument in a DocumentGroup?
I have a DocumentGroup working with a FileDocument, and that's fine. However, when someone creates a new document I want them to have to immediately save it. This is the behavior on ipadOS and iOS from what I can understand (you select where before the file is created). There seems to be no way to do this on macOS? I basically want to have someone: create a new document enter some basic data hit "create" which saves the file then lets the user start editing it (1), (2), and (4) are done and fairly trivial. (3) seems impossible, though...? This really only needs to support macOS but any pointers would be appreciated.
0
0
284
Apr ’25
Unable to Drag 3D Model(Entity) in visionOS when UITextView Is in the Background
I'm running into an issue in Xcode when working on a visionOS app. Whenever I try to drag a 3D model entity in my scene, the drag gesture doesn't work if there's a UITextView (or SwiftUI TextEditor) in background of the 3D entity. It seems like the UITextView is intercepting the gesture or preventing the drag interaction from reaching the 3D content. Interestingly, when the 3D entity is placed infront of the ScrollView, the drag works as expected. Has anyone else experienced this behavior? Is this a known limitation or a bug in the current tooling? Any workarounds or fixes would be appreciated. Thanks!
0
0
219
Jul ’25
View lifecycle in Tabview
In TabView, when I open a view in a Tab, and I switch to another Tab, but the View lifecycle of the view in the old Tab is still not over, and the threads of some functions are still in the background. I want to completely end the View lifecycle of the View in the previously opened tab when switching Tab. How can I do it? Thank you!
0
0
185
Jul ’25
Using NSHostingSceneRepresentation to open arbitrary window in AppKit app
I’m trying to open a window from a SwiftUI Scene inside an AppKit app using NSHostingSceneRepresentation (macOS 26). The idea is that I want to call openWindow(id: "some-id") to show the new window. However, nothing happens when I try this — no window appears, and there’s nothing in the logs. Interestingly, if I use the openSettings() route instead, it does open a window. Does anyone know the correct way to open an arbitrary SwiftUI window scene from an AppKit app? import Cocoa import SwiftUI @main class AppDelegate: NSObject, NSApplicationDelegate { let settingsScene = NSHostingSceneRepresentation { #if true MyWindowScene() #else Settings { Text("My Settings") } #endif } func applicationWillFinishLaunching(_ notification: Notification) { NSApplication.shared.addSceneRepresentation(settingsScene) } @IBAction func showAppSettings(_ sender: NSMenuItem) { #if true settingsScene.environment.openWindow(id: MyWindowScene.windowID) #else settingsScene.environment.openSettings() #endif } } struct MyWindowScene: Scene { static let windowID = "com.company.MySampleApp.myWindow" var body: some Scene { Window("Sample Window", id: MyWindowScene.windowID) { Text("Sample Content") .scenePadding() } } }
Topic: UI Frameworks SubTopic: SwiftUI
0
0
120
Jul ’25
Crash due to likely infinitely recursive call in SwiftUI `Color.Resolved.init`
So I'm dealing with a really obtuse crash that appears to be a stack overflow in an internal SwiftUI code path creating a Color.Resolved. I haven't found anyone one else with this issue online, and I cannot get it to reproduce on my own device. Interestingly enough, it is only happening on 1 device in the field (according to XCode crash logs). Here are some lines from the crashed thread. You can see that my code is never called, and it appears to be starting in some Array equality check checking the equality of colors (which I can't think of anywhere in my app I am doing anyway). You can see from this trace here that it appears to be a recursive call through Color.Resolved and NSColor.withColorAppearance. I don't have any idea how to solve this, but it keeps happening with at least one in-the-field device across multiple app updates. So my whole app is open source on github at https://github.com/msdrigg/roam, but I don't even use NSColor explicitly anywhere except for here which doesn't match the stack trace. I also tried changing the accent color of the app with defaults write com.msdrigg.roam AppleAccentColor -integer 1 to see if that somehow caused the crash, but my app opened up totally fine (and respected the change). Besides this, the only places I think I could be using dynamic colors is I when define an AccentColor and a WidgetBackground color for my app using xcassets, and then I use these colors from SwiftUI. In most of my app I stick to the system colors (Color.gray and such). Thread 0 Crashed: 0 libsystem_pthread.dylib 0x000000018601213c ___chkstk_darwin + 60 1 CoreFoundation 0x0000000186108434 -[NSArray isEqualToArray:] + 52 (NSArray.m:454) 2 AppKit 0x000000018a21fcd4 -[NSCoreUICatalogColor resolvedCUINamedColorForAppearance:] + 164 (NSColor.m:5057) 3 AppKit 0x0000000189c32cd4 -[NSCoreUICatalogColor resolvedColor] + 48 (NSColor.m:5148) 4 AppKit 0x0000000189c31e74 -[NSDynamicNamedColor colorUsingColorSpace:] + 32 (NSColor.m:4410) 5 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221ca9fd8 CoreColorPlatformColorGetComponents + 116 (CoreColorFunctions.m:149) 6 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faaf28 specialized Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 92 (CoreColor.swift:14) 7 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faa5b0 Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 16 (<compiler-generated>:0) 8 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1dc4 closure #1 in NSColor.resolve(in:) + 20 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:156) 9 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b222c partial apply for closure #1 in static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 32 (<compiler-generated>:0) 10 SwiftUI 0x00000001b46b1e54 closure #1 in SubmitTriggerSource.dispatchUpdate(_:) + 28 (PlatformViewCoordinator.swift:12) 11 SwiftUI 0x00000001b5484488 thunk for @escaping @callee_guaranteed () -> () + 28 (<compiler-generated>:0) 12 AppKit 0x0000000189c174a4 +[NSAppearance _performWithCurrentAppearance:usingBlock:] + 72 (NSAppearance.m:2408) 13 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b2088 specialized static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 324 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:142) 14 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1e7c protocol witness for ColorProvider.resolve(in:) in conformance NSColor + 68 (<compiler-generated>:151) 15 SwiftUICore 0x0000000222436e6c ColorBox.resolve(in:) + 124 (Color.swift:288) 16 SwiftUICore 0x0000000222435e30 Color.resolve(in:) + 72 (Color.swift:87) 17 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1c88 closure #1 in NSColor.init(_:) + 196 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:124) 18 SwiftUI 0x00000001b4542714 thunk for @escaping @callee_guaranteed (@guaranteed NSAppearance) -> (@owned NSColor) + 56 (<compiler-generated>:0) 19 AppKit 0x0000000189c31e74 -[NSDynamicNamedColor colorUsingColorSpace:] + 32 (NSColor.m:4410) //// ... Repeating for 500 lines 500 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221ca9fd8 CoreColorPlatformColorGetComponents + 116 (CoreColorFunctions.m:149) 501 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faaf28 specialized Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 92 (CoreColor.swift:14) 502 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faa5b0 Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 16 (<compiler-generated>:0) 503 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1dc4 closure #1 in NSColor.resolve(in:) + 20 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:156) 504 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b222c partial apply for closure #1 in static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 32 (<compiler-generated>:0) 505 SwiftUI 0x00000001b46b1e54 closure #1 in SubmitTriggerSource.dispatchUpdate(_:) + 28 (PlatformViewCoordinator.swift:12) 506 SwiftUI 0x00000001b5484488 thunk for @escaping @callee_guaranteed () -> () + 28 (<compiler-generated>:0) 507 AppKit 0x0000000189c174a4 +[NSAppearance _performWithCurrentAppearance:usingBlock:] + 72 (NSAppearance.m:2408) 508 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b2088 specialized static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 324 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:142) 509 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1e7c protocol witness for ColorProvider.resolve(in:) in conformance NSColor + 68 (<compiler-generated>:151) 510 SwiftUICore 0x0000000222436e6c ColorBox.resolve(in:) + 124 (Color.swift:288) full-log.crash
0
0
135
May ’25
Enabling Show Tab Bar Programmatically
I have a macOS application developed in SwiftUI. It's a document-based application. I know how to hide the Show Tab Bar command under View. I don't want to hide it. I always want to show tabs. I wonder how to enable this command programmatically such that the document window always has the + button to the right. Thanks.
0
0
119
May ’25
Food-Truck-Sample navigation broken from Live Activity?
https://github.com/apple/sample-food-truck Hi! I'm seeing what looks like some weird navigation issue in the Food Truck app. It's from the Live Activity that should deep link to a specific point in the app. There seems be some state where the app is not linking to the correct component. Here are my repro steps on iPhone: Start live activity from OrderDetailView. Navigate to Sidebar component. Tap the Live Activity. App opens TruckView. The App should be opening the OrderDetailView for the Order that was passed to the Live Activity. This seems to work when the app is not currently on Sidebar. Any ideas? I'm testing this on iPhone OS 18.4.1. Is this an issue inside NavigationSplitView? Is this an issue with how Food Truck handles deeplinking?
0
0
71
May ’25
Using NavigationSplitView with NavigationStack in it with variable navigation depth (2 and 3 levels) — unexpected back navigation on iPhone
I’m building a cross-platform app targeting macOS, iPad, and iPhone. My app currently uses both 2-level and 3-level navigation workflows: 3-level navigation: First level: Categories Second level: List of items in the selected category Third level: Detail view for a specific item 2-level navigation: First level: Category Second level: A singleton detail view (for example, StatusView). It does not have concept of List. After watching a couple of WWDC videos about multi-platform navigation, I decided to go with NavigationSplitView. However, on macOS, a 3-column NavigationSplitView felt a bit overwhelming to my eyes when the third column was empty—especially for the occasional 2-level navigation case. So I removed the third column and instead embedded a NavigationStack in the second column. According to the official Apple documentation, this is supported: You can also embed a NavigationStack in a column. The code with NavigationStack in NavigationSplitView works fine on macOS. But on iPhone, for the same code I’m seeing unexpected behavior: The first time I tap on the “Actions” category, it briefly shows the “Select an item” view, and then automatically pops back to the all-categories view. If I tap the same "Actions" category again, it shows the list of actions correctly, and everything works fine until I terminate and relaunch the app. Here is a minimal reproducible example: import SwiftUI struct StatusView: View { var body: some View { NavigationStack { List { Text("Heartbeat: OK") Text("Connected to backend: OK") } } } } struct ActionListView: View { var body: some View { NavigationStack { List { NavigationLink(value: "Action 1 value") { Text("Action 1 label") } NavigationLink(value: "Action 2 value") { Text("Action 2 label") } } } .navigationDestination(for: String.self) { action in Text(action) } } } struct ContentView: View { var body: some View { NavigationSplitView { List { NavigationLink(value: "Actions") { Text("Actions (3 level)") } NavigationLink(value: "Modes") { Text("Modes (3 level)") } NavigationLink(value: "State") { Text("Status (2 level)") } } .navigationDestination(for: String.self) { category in switch category { case "Actions": ActionListView() case "Modes": Text("Modes View") case "State": StatusView() default: Text("Unknown Category") } } } detail: { Text("Select an item") } } } Questions and considerations: How can I prevent this unexpected automatic pop back to the root view on iPhone the first time I select a category? Future-proofing for more than 3 level navigation: In the future, I may allow users to navigate beyond three levels (e.g., an item in one category can reference another item in a different category). Is it correct to assume that to support this with back navigation, I’d need to keep using NavigationStack inside NavigationSplitView? Is embedding NavigationStack in a 2 column NavigationSplitView the only practical approach to handle mixed 2 and 3 navigation depth if I don't want the third column to be ever empty? On macOS, NavigationStack alone doesn’t feel appropriate for sidebar-based navigation. Does it mean everyone on macOS pretty much always use NavigationSplitView? Any advice or examples would be appreciated. Thanks!
Topic: UI Frameworks SubTopic: SwiftUI
0
0
134
Jul ’25
How do I maintain a stable scroll position when inserting items above in a ScrollView?
As the title says, I am not sure how to properly build an inverted ScrollView where I can safely insert items above my data ("prepend") without everything jumping around. My current code is essentially this: @State private var scrollPosition = ScrollPosition(idType: Message.ID.self) private func onMessageDidScrollIntoView(_ id: Message.ID) { let indexOfVisibleMessage = /* ... */ if indexOfVisibleMessage < 10 { fetchOlderMessages() // ^ this updates my ViewModel `messages` } } var body: some View { ScrollView { LazyVStack { ForEach(messages) { message in MessageCell(message) } }.scrollTargetLayout() } .defaultScrollAnchor(.bottom) .scrollPosition($scrollPosition) .onChange(of: scrollPosition) { oldValue, newValue in guard let visibleMessageId = scrollPosition.viewID(type: Message.ID.self) else { return } onMessageDidScrollIntoView(visibleMessageId) } } ..so if the user scrolls up to the oldest 10 messages, I start loading more and insert them at the top. The problem with this is that the ScrollView now jumps when new messages are inserted. This is because the ScrollView maintains it's Y position, but the content size changes since we are adding new items "above". I tried to play around with a few suggestions I found on StackOverflow, namely; Inverting the ScrollView (.scaleEffect(y: -1) on the ScrollView and then again on the MessageCell to counter it): This somehow jumped the x position of the ScrollView and completely breaks .contextMenu. Playing around with .onScrollGeometryChange to update scrollPosition.scrollTo(y:) when it's contentSize changes: This just didn't work and stopped the user scroll gesture/interaction. Setting scrollPosition to the Message.ID I want to keep stable before doing an update: This didn't do anything. But nothing actually worked for the reasons described above. How do you actually build these UIs in SwiftUI? I think an inverted ScrollView is quite a common UI, and obviously data has to be loaded lazily.
0
1
122
Apr ’25
Tap area for focusing element during voice over is not correct
I have two overlay views on each side of a horizontal scroll. The overlay views are helper arrow buttons that can be used to scroll quickly. This issue occurs when I use either ZStack or .overlay modifier for layout. I am using accessibilitySortPriority modifier to maintain this reading order. Left Overlay View Horizontal Scroll Items Right Overlay View When voiceover is on and i do a single tap on views, the focus shifts to particular view as expected. But for the trailing overlay view, the focus does not shift to it as expected. Instead, the focus goes to the scroll item behind it.
0
0
61
Jul ’25
A wrinkle converting a UIKit Document-based app to SwiftUI Document Group
The app I'm converting includes two unique document types. UI-wise they have key similarities (eg contents are password protected) But serialization/model - wise. they are different documents. I have not been able to find any documentation on options for implementing this (eg use a (abstract?) base class derived from FileDocument, with two concrete sub classes? maybe just a single subclass of FileDocument that contains model details for both file types?) Stepping back from implementation options, am I crazy for attempting to use DocumentGroup to create a single app that would need to be able to open/modify/save multiple unique document types? any/all guidance much appreciated.
Topic: UI Frameworks SubTopic: SwiftUI
0
0
73
May ’25
UI not updating during render
I've coded a small raytracer that renders a scene (based on Peter Shirley's tutorial, I just coded it in Swift). The raytracer itself works fine, outputs a PPM file which is correct. However, I was hoping to enclose this in a UI that will update the picture as each pixel value gets updated during the render. So to that end I made a MacOS app, with a basic model-view architecture. Here is my model: // // RGBViewModel.swift // rtweekend_gui // // import SwiftUI // RGB structure to hold color values struct RGB { var r: UInt8 var g: UInt8 var b: UInt8 } // ViewModel to handle the RGB array and updates class RGBViewModel: ObservableObject { // Define the dimensions of your 2D array let width = 1200 let height = 675 // Published property to trigger UI updates @Published var rgbArray: [[RGB]] init() { // Initialize with black pixels rgbArray = Array(repeating: Array(repeating: RGB(r: 0, g: 0, b: 0), count: width), count: height) } func render_scene() { for j in 0..&lt;height { for i in 0..&lt;width { // Generate a random color let r = UInt8.random(in: 0...255) let g = UInt8.random(in: 0...255) let b = UInt8.random(in: 0...255) // Update on the main thread since this affects the UI DispatchQueue.main.async { // Update the array self.rgbArray[j][i] = RGB(r: r, g: g, b: b) } } } } and here is my view: // // RGBArrayView.swift // rtweekend_gui // // import SwiftUI struct RGBArrayView: View { // The 2D array of RGB values @StateObject private var viewModel = RGBViewModel() // Control the size of each pixel private let pixelSize: CGFloat = 1 var body: some View { VStack { // Display the RGB array Canvas { context, size in for y in 0..&lt;viewModel.rgbArray.count { for x in 0..&lt;viewModel.rgbArray[y].count { let rgb = viewModel.rgbArray[y][x] let rect = CGRect( x: CGFloat(x) * pixelSize, y: CGFloat(y) * pixelSize, width: pixelSize, height: pixelSize ) context.fill( Path(rect), with: .color(Color( red: Double(rgb.r) / 255.0, green: Double(rgb.g) / 255.0, blue: Double(rgb.b) / 255.0 )) ) } } } .border(Color.gray) // Button to start filling the array Button("Render") { viewModel.render_scene() } .padding() } .padding() .frame(width: CGFloat(viewModel.width) * pixelSize + 40, height: CGFloat(viewModel.height) * pixelSize + 80) } } // Preview for SwiftUI struct RGBArrayView_Previews: PreviewProvider { static var previews: some View { RGBArrayView() } } The render does work and the image displays, however, I thought I set it up to show the image updating pixel by pixel and that doesn't happen, the image shows up all at once. What am I doing wrong?
0
0
99
May ’25
Can SwiftUI TextFields in a List on macOS be marked as always editable?
In SwiftUI's List, on macOS, if I embed a TextField then the text field is presented as non-editable. If the user clicks on the text and waits a short period of time, the text field will become editable. I'm aware this is generally the correct behaviour for macOS. However, is there a way in SwiftUI to supress this behaviour such that the TextField is always presented as being editable? I want a scrollable, List of editable text fields, much like how a Form is presented. The reason I'm not using a Form is because I want List's support for reordering by drag-and-drop (.onMove). Use Case A view that allows a user to compose a questionnaire. They are able to add and remove questions (rows) and each question is editable. They require drag-and-drop support so that they can reorder the questions.
0
0
147
May ’25
[SwiftUI] SecureEntry Autofill in Dark Mode
When using New Password Autofill in Dark Mode, it appears that SecureEntry sets the background color to white and applies a yellow-ish overlay, but doesn't adapt the foreground text color accordingly. This gives the illusion that the SecureEntry field is empty, as we have white text on a white background. Is there a holistic and SwiftUI-native way of fixing this?
0
0
59
Apr ’25
Navbar buttons disappear in NavigationSplitView's sidebar when changing apps
We recently migrated our app to use NavigationSplitView on iPad with a sidebar and detail setup, and we got reports that the navigation buttons on the sidebar disappear when returning to our app after using a different app. I reproduced the issue from a new empty project with the following code (issue tested on iOS 17.4 and iOS 18.3, was not able to reproduce on iOS 16.4): import SwiftUI @main struct TestApp: App { var body: some Scene { WindowGroup { NavigationSplitView { Text("sidebar") .toolbar { ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarLeading) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "square.and.arrow.down") } } ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarTrailing) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "square.and.arrow.up") } } } } detail: { Text("detail") .toolbar { ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarLeading) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "eraser") } } ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarTrailing) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "pencil") } } } } } } } Please check the following GIF for the simple steps, notice how the navbar buttons in the detail view do not disappear: Here's the console output, it shows that the constraints break internally:
0
0
128
Apr ’25
White flash using manageSubscriptionsSheet in SwiftUI
In SwiftUI I am using the manageSubscriptionsSheet modifier to open the iOS subscription screen. When this is presented it immediately flashes a white view and then animated the subscription screen up from the bottom, it looks pretty bad. The view I am calling manageSubscriptionsSheet on is presented in a sheet, so maybe trying to present the subscriptions view as well is causing the visual glitch. Any way to not have this white flashing view when opening the subscription screen?
0
0
161
Oct ’25
Canvas Is Not Updating in Xcode 26
I just updated to Tahoe 26 and Xcode 26, and now a SwiftUI project that was working just fine, simply shows a blank canvas. I closed Xcode and reopened, but get the same results. Note that there is no error message and the project builds and displays normally. Steps to blank canvas: Open Xcode I see Canvas Paused Click on the circle The Form opens with a blank screen Build the project The Form opens with all controls showing Jim
0
0
183
Oct ’25
Trigger save of a FileDocument in a DocumentGroup?
I have a DocumentGroup working with a FileDocument, and that's fine. However, when someone creates a new document I want them to have to immediately save it. This is the behavior on ipadOS and iOS from what I can understand (you select where before the file is created). There seems to be no way to do this on macOS? I basically want to have someone: create a new document enter some basic data hit "create" which saves the file then lets the user start editing it (1), (2), and (4) are done and fairly trivial. (3) seems impossible, though...? This really only needs to support macOS but any pointers would be appreciated.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
284
Activity
Apr ’25
SwiftUI WebView in sheet not honoring swipe to dismiss
I’ve got the new SwiftUi webview in a sheet. When I pull down the contents from the top of the page I expect it to dismiss the sheet, but it does not. Is there a workaround or modifier I’m missing?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
168
Activity
Aug ’25
Unable to Drag 3D Model(Entity) in visionOS when UITextView Is in the Background
I'm running into an issue in Xcode when working on a visionOS app. Whenever I try to drag a 3D model entity in my scene, the drag gesture doesn't work if there's a UITextView (or SwiftUI TextEditor) in background of the 3D entity. It seems like the UITextView is intercepting the gesture or preventing the drag interaction from reaching the 3D content. Interestingly, when the 3D entity is placed infront of the ScrollView, the drag works as expected. Has anyone else experienced this behavior? Is this a known limitation or a bug in the current tooling? Any workarounds or fixes would be appreciated. Thanks!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
219
Activity
Jul ’25
View lifecycle in Tabview
In TabView, when I open a view in a Tab, and I switch to another Tab, but the View lifecycle of the view in the old Tab is still not over, and the threads of some functions are still in the background. I want to completely end the View lifecycle of the View in the previously opened tab when switching Tab. How can I do it? Thank you!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
185
Activity
Jul ’25
Highlight the model not with the eyes, but by clicking a button
Hello, we have a requirement where clicking a button will highlight the model, similar to the effect seen by the eyes. However, the eyes do not see it and it is achieved by clicking a button. What should we do? Thank you for your reply
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
139
Activity
Jun ’25
Using NSHostingSceneRepresentation to open arbitrary window in AppKit app
I’m trying to open a window from a SwiftUI Scene inside an AppKit app using NSHostingSceneRepresentation (macOS 26). The idea is that I want to call openWindow(id: "some-id") to show the new window. However, nothing happens when I try this — no window appears, and there’s nothing in the logs. Interestingly, if I use the openSettings() route instead, it does open a window. Does anyone know the correct way to open an arbitrary SwiftUI window scene from an AppKit app? import Cocoa import SwiftUI @main class AppDelegate: NSObject, NSApplicationDelegate { let settingsScene = NSHostingSceneRepresentation { #if true MyWindowScene() #else Settings { Text("My Settings") } #endif } func applicationWillFinishLaunching(_ notification: Notification) { NSApplication.shared.addSceneRepresentation(settingsScene) } @IBAction func showAppSettings(_ sender: NSMenuItem) { #if true settingsScene.environment.openWindow(id: MyWindowScene.windowID) #else settingsScene.environment.openSettings() #endif } } struct MyWindowScene: Scene { static let windowID = "com.company.MySampleApp.myWindow" var body: some Scene { Window("Sample Window", id: MyWindowScene.windowID) { Text("Sample Content") .scenePadding() } } }
Topic: UI Frameworks SubTopic: SwiftUI
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
120
Activity
Jul ’25
Crash due to likely infinitely recursive call in SwiftUI `Color.Resolved.init`
So I'm dealing with a really obtuse crash that appears to be a stack overflow in an internal SwiftUI code path creating a Color.Resolved. I haven't found anyone one else with this issue online, and I cannot get it to reproduce on my own device. Interestingly enough, it is only happening on 1 device in the field (according to XCode crash logs). Here are some lines from the crashed thread. You can see that my code is never called, and it appears to be starting in some Array equality check checking the equality of colors (which I can't think of anywhere in my app I am doing anyway). You can see from this trace here that it appears to be a recursive call through Color.Resolved and NSColor.withColorAppearance. I don't have any idea how to solve this, but it keeps happening with at least one in-the-field device across multiple app updates. So my whole app is open source on github at https://github.com/msdrigg/roam, but I don't even use NSColor explicitly anywhere except for here which doesn't match the stack trace. I also tried changing the accent color of the app with defaults write com.msdrigg.roam AppleAccentColor -integer 1 to see if that somehow caused the crash, but my app opened up totally fine (and respected the change). Besides this, the only places I think I could be using dynamic colors is I when define an AccentColor and a WidgetBackground color for my app using xcassets, and then I use these colors from SwiftUI. In most of my app I stick to the system colors (Color.gray and such). Thread 0 Crashed: 0 libsystem_pthread.dylib 0x000000018601213c ___chkstk_darwin + 60 1 CoreFoundation 0x0000000186108434 -[NSArray isEqualToArray:] + 52 (NSArray.m:454) 2 AppKit 0x000000018a21fcd4 -[NSCoreUICatalogColor resolvedCUINamedColorForAppearance:] + 164 (NSColor.m:5057) 3 AppKit 0x0000000189c32cd4 -[NSCoreUICatalogColor resolvedColor] + 48 (NSColor.m:5148) 4 AppKit 0x0000000189c31e74 -[NSDynamicNamedColor colorUsingColorSpace:] + 32 (NSColor.m:4410) 5 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221ca9fd8 CoreColorPlatformColorGetComponents + 116 (CoreColorFunctions.m:149) 6 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faaf28 specialized Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 92 (CoreColor.swift:14) 7 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faa5b0 Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 16 (<compiler-generated>:0) 8 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1dc4 closure #1 in NSColor.resolve(in:) + 20 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:156) 9 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b222c partial apply for closure #1 in static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 32 (<compiler-generated>:0) 10 SwiftUI 0x00000001b46b1e54 closure #1 in SubmitTriggerSource.dispatchUpdate(_:) + 28 (PlatformViewCoordinator.swift:12) 11 SwiftUI 0x00000001b5484488 thunk for @escaping @callee_guaranteed () -> () + 28 (<compiler-generated>:0) 12 AppKit 0x0000000189c174a4 +[NSAppearance _performWithCurrentAppearance:usingBlock:] + 72 (NSAppearance.m:2408) 13 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b2088 specialized static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 324 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:142) 14 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1e7c protocol witness for ColorProvider.resolve(in:) in conformance NSColor + 68 (<compiler-generated>:151) 15 SwiftUICore 0x0000000222436e6c ColorBox.resolve(in:) + 124 (Color.swift:288) 16 SwiftUICore 0x0000000222435e30 Color.resolve(in:) + 72 (Color.swift:87) 17 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1c88 closure #1 in NSColor.init(_:) + 196 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:124) 18 SwiftUI 0x00000001b4542714 thunk for @escaping @callee_guaranteed (@guaranteed NSAppearance) -> (@owned NSColor) + 56 (<compiler-generated>:0) 19 AppKit 0x0000000189c31e74 -[NSDynamicNamedColor colorUsingColorSpace:] + 32 (NSColor.m:4410) //// ... Repeating for 500 lines 500 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221ca9fd8 CoreColorPlatformColorGetComponents + 116 (CoreColorFunctions.m:149) 501 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faaf28 specialized Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 92 (CoreColor.swift:14) 502 SwiftUICore 0x0000000221faa5b0 Color.Resolved.init(platformColor:) + 16 (<compiler-generated>:0) 503 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1dc4 closure #1 in NSColor.resolve(in:) + 20 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:156) 504 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b222c partial apply for closure #1 in static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 32 (<compiler-generated>:0) 505 SwiftUI 0x00000001b46b1e54 closure #1 in SubmitTriggerSource.dispatchUpdate(_:) + 28 (PlatformViewCoordinator.swift:12) 506 SwiftUI 0x00000001b5484488 thunk for @escaping @callee_guaranteed () -> () + 28 (<compiler-generated>:0) 507 AppKit 0x0000000189c174a4 +[NSAppearance _performWithCurrentAppearance:usingBlock:] + 72 (NSAppearance.m:2408) 508 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b2088 specialized static NSColor.withColorAppearance(in:_:) + 324 (AppKitColorConversions.swift:142) 509 SwiftUI 0x00000001b53b1e7c protocol witness for ColorProvider.resolve(in:) in conformance NSColor + 68 (<compiler-generated>:151) 510 SwiftUICore 0x0000000222436e6c ColorBox.resolve(in:) + 124 (Color.swift:288) full-log.crash
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
135
Activity
May ’25
Enabling Show Tab Bar Programmatically
I have a macOS application developed in SwiftUI. It's a document-based application. I know how to hide the Show Tab Bar command under View. I don't want to hide it. I always want to show tabs. I wonder how to enable this command programmatically such that the document window always has the + button to the right. Thanks.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
119
Activity
May ’25
Food-Truck-Sample navigation broken from Live Activity?
https://github.com/apple/sample-food-truck Hi! I'm seeing what looks like some weird navigation issue in the Food Truck app. It's from the Live Activity that should deep link to a specific point in the app. There seems be some state where the app is not linking to the correct component. Here are my repro steps on iPhone: Start live activity from OrderDetailView. Navigate to Sidebar component. Tap the Live Activity. App opens TruckView. The App should be opening the OrderDetailView for the Order that was passed to the Live Activity. This seems to work when the app is not currently on Sidebar. Any ideas? I'm testing this on iPhone OS 18.4.1. Is this an issue inside NavigationSplitView? Is this an issue with how Food Truck handles deeplinking?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
71
Activity
May ’25
Using NavigationSplitView with NavigationStack in it with variable navigation depth (2 and 3 levels) — unexpected back navigation on iPhone
I’m building a cross-platform app targeting macOS, iPad, and iPhone. My app currently uses both 2-level and 3-level navigation workflows: 3-level navigation: First level: Categories Second level: List of items in the selected category Third level: Detail view for a specific item 2-level navigation: First level: Category Second level: A singleton detail view (for example, StatusView). It does not have concept of List. After watching a couple of WWDC videos about multi-platform navigation, I decided to go with NavigationSplitView. However, on macOS, a 3-column NavigationSplitView felt a bit overwhelming to my eyes when the third column was empty—especially for the occasional 2-level navigation case. So I removed the third column and instead embedded a NavigationStack in the second column. According to the official Apple documentation, this is supported: You can also embed a NavigationStack in a column. The code with NavigationStack in NavigationSplitView works fine on macOS. But on iPhone, for the same code I’m seeing unexpected behavior: The first time I tap on the “Actions” category, it briefly shows the “Select an item” view, and then automatically pops back to the all-categories view. If I tap the same "Actions" category again, it shows the list of actions correctly, and everything works fine until I terminate and relaunch the app. Here is a minimal reproducible example: import SwiftUI struct StatusView: View { var body: some View { NavigationStack { List { Text("Heartbeat: OK") Text("Connected to backend: OK") } } } } struct ActionListView: View { var body: some View { NavigationStack { List { NavigationLink(value: "Action 1 value") { Text("Action 1 label") } NavigationLink(value: "Action 2 value") { Text("Action 2 label") } } } .navigationDestination(for: String.self) { action in Text(action) } } } struct ContentView: View { var body: some View { NavigationSplitView { List { NavigationLink(value: "Actions") { Text("Actions (3 level)") } NavigationLink(value: "Modes") { Text("Modes (3 level)") } NavigationLink(value: "State") { Text("Status (2 level)") } } .navigationDestination(for: String.self) { category in switch category { case "Actions": ActionListView() case "Modes": Text("Modes View") case "State": StatusView() default: Text("Unknown Category") } } } detail: { Text("Select an item") } } } Questions and considerations: How can I prevent this unexpected automatic pop back to the root view on iPhone the first time I select a category? Future-proofing for more than 3 level navigation: In the future, I may allow users to navigate beyond three levels (e.g., an item in one category can reference another item in a different category). Is it correct to assume that to support this with back navigation, I’d need to keep using NavigationStack inside NavigationSplitView? Is embedding NavigationStack in a 2 column NavigationSplitView the only practical approach to handle mixed 2 and 3 navigation depth if I don't want the third column to be ever empty? On macOS, NavigationStack alone doesn’t feel appropriate for sidebar-based navigation. Does it mean everyone on macOS pretty much always use NavigationSplitView? Any advice or examples would be appreciated. Thanks!
Topic: UI Frameworks SubTopic: SwiftUI
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
134
Activity
Jul ’25
How do I maintain a stable scroll position when inserting items above in a ScrollView?
As the title says, I am not sure how to properly build an inverted ScrollView where I can safely insert items above my data ("prepend") without everything jumping around. My current code is essentially this: @State private var scrollPosition = ScrollPosition(idType: Message.ID.self) private func onMessageDidScrollIntoView(_ id: Message.ID) { let indexOfVisibleMessage = /* ... */ if indexOfVisibleMessage < 10 { fetchOlderMessages() // ^ this updates my ViewModel `messages` } } var body: some View { ScrollView { LazyVStack { ForEach(messages) { message in MessageCell(message) } }.scrollTargetLayout() } .defaultScrollAnchor(.bottom) .scrollPosition($scrollPosition) .onChange(of: scrollPosition) { oldValue, newValue in guard let visibleMessageId = scrollPosition.viewID(type: Message.ID.self) else { return } onMessageDidScrollIntoView(visibleMessageId) } } ..so if the user scrolls up to the oldest 10 messages, I start loading more and insert them at the top. The problem with this is that the ScrollView now jumps when new messages are inserted. This is because the ScrollView maintains it's Y position, but the content size changes since we are adding new items "above". I tried to play around with a few suggestions I found on StackOverflow, namely; Inverting the ScrollView (.scaleEffect(y: -1) on the ScrollView and then again on the MessageCell to counter it): This somehow jumped the x position of the ScrollView and completely breaks .contextMenu. Playing around with .onScrollGeometryChange to update scrollPosition.scrollTo(y:) when it's contentSize changes: This just didn't work and stopped the user scroll gesture/interaction. Setting scrollPosition to the Message.ID I want to keep stable before doing an update: This didn't do anything. But nothing actually worked for the reasons described above. How do you actually build these UIs in SwiftUI? I think an inverted ScrollView is quite a common UI, and obviously data has to be loaded lazily.
Replies
0
Boosts
1
Views
122
Activity
Apr ’25
Tap area for focusing element during voice over is not correct
I have two overlay views on each side of a horizontal scroll. The overlay views are helper arrow buttons that can be used to scroll quickly. This issue occurs when I use either ZStack or .overlay modifier for layout. I am using accessibilitySortPriority modifier to maintain this reading order. Left Overlay View Horizontal Scroll Items Right Overlay View When voiceover is on and i do a single tap on views, the focus shifts to particular view as expected. But for the trailing overlay view, the focus does not shift to it as expected. Instead, the focus goes to the scroll item behind it.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
61
Activity
Jul ’25
A wrinkle converting a UIKit Document-based app to SwiftUI Document Group
The app I'm converting includes two unique document types. UI-wise they have key similarities (eg contents are password protected) But serialization/model - wise. they are different documents. I have not been able to find any documentation on options for implementing this (eg use a (abstract?) base class derived from FileDocument, with two concrete sub classes? maybe just a single subclass of FileDocument that contains model details for both file types?) Stepping back from implementation options, am I crazy for attempting to use DocumentGroup to create a single app that would need to be able to open/modify/save multiple unique document types? any/all guidance much appreciated.
Topic: UI Frameworks SubTopic: SwiftUI
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
73
Activity
May ’25
UI not updating during render
I've coded a small raytracer that renders a scene (based on Peter Shirley's tutorial, I just coded it in Swift). The raytracer itself works fine, outputs a PPM file which is correct. However, I was hoping to enclose this in a UI that will update the picture as each pixel value gets updated during the render. So to that end I made a MacOS app, with a basic model-view architecture. Here is my model: // // RGBViewModel.swift // rtweekend_gui // // import SwiftUI // RGB structure to hold color values struct RGB { var r: UInt8 var g: UInt8 var b: UInt8 } // ViewModel to handle the RGB array and updates class RGBViewModel: ObservableObject { // Define the dimensions of your 2D array let width = 1200 let height = 675 // Published property to trigger UI updates @Published var rgbArray: [[RGB]] init() { // Initialize with black pixels rgbArray = Array(repeating: Array(repeating: RGB(r: 0, g: 0, b: 0), count: width), count: height) } func render_scene() { for j in 0..&lt;height { for i in 0..&lt;width { // Generate a random color let r = UInt8.random(in: 0...255) let g = UInt8.random(in: 0...255) let b = UInt8.random(in: 0...255) // Update on the main thread since this affects the UI DispatchQueue.main.async { // Update the array self.rgbArray[j][i] = RGB(r: r, g: g, b: b) } } } } and here is my view: // // RGBArrayView.swift // rtweekend_gui // // import SwiftUI struct RGBArrayView: View { // The 2D array of RGB values @StateObject private var viewModel = RGBViewModel() // Control the size of each pixel private let pixelSize: CGFloat = 1 var body: some View { VStack { // Display the RGB array Canvas { context, size in for y in 0..&lt;viewModel.rgbArray.count { for x in 0..&lt;viewModel.rgbArray[y].count { let rgb = viewModel.rgbArray[y][x] let rect = CGRect( x: CGFloat(x) * pixelSize, y: CGFloat(y) * pixelSize, width: pixelSize, height: pixelSize ) context.fill( Path(rect), with: .color(Color( red: Double(rgb.r) / 255.0, green: Double(rgb.g) / 255.0, blue: Double(rgb.b) / 255.0 )) ) } } } .border(Color.gray) // Button to start filling the array Button("Render") { viewModel.render_scene() } .padding() } .padding() .frame(width: CGFloat(viewModel.width) * pixelSize + 40, height: CGFloat(viewModel.height) * pixelSize + 80) } } // Preview for SwiftUI struct RGBArrayView_Previews: PreviewProvider { static var previews: some View { RGBArrayView() } } The render does work and the image displays, however, I thought I set it up to show the image updating pixel by pixel and that doesn't happen, the image shows up all at once. What am I doing wrong?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
99
Activity
May ’25
Can SwiftUI TextFields in a List on macOS be marked as always editable?
In SwiftUI's List, on macOS, if I embed a TextField then the text field is presented as non-editable. If the user clicks on the text and waits a short period of time, the text field will become editable. I'm aware this is generally the correct behaviour for macOS. However, is there a way in SwiftUI to supress this behaviour such that the TextField is always presented as being editable? I want a scrollable, List of editable text fields, much like how a Form is presented. The reason I'm not using a Form is because I want List's support for reordering by drag-and-drop (.onMove). Use Case A view that allows a user to compose a questionnaire. They are able to add and remove questions (rows) and each question is editable. They require drag-and-drop support so that they can reorder the questions.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
147
Activity
May ’25
[SwiftUI] SecureEntry Autofill in Dark Mode
When using New Password Autofill in Dark Mode, it appears that SecureEntry sets the background color to white and applies a yellow-ish overlay, but doesn't adapt the foreground text color accordingly. This gives the illusion that the SecureEntry field is empty, as we have white text on a white background. Is there a holistic and SwiftUI-native way of fixing this?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
59
Activity
Apr ’25
Swift Playground Canvas Interaction Not Working
I am currently do the 'Keep Going with Apps' book in Playground. When I open the book on my iPad and MacBook, the canvas interaction does not work. I have tried restarting and reinstalling the book as well. I am on the latest OS and everything else is up to date as far as I can tell.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
246
Activity
Oct ’25
Navbar buttons disappear in NavigationSplitView's sidebar when changing apps
We recently migrated our app to use NavigationSplitView on iPad with a sidebar and detail setup, and we got reports that the navigation buttons on the sidebar disappear when returning to our app after using a different app. I reproduced the issue from a new empty project with the following code (issue tested on iOS 17.4 and iOS 18.3, was not able to reproduce on iOS 16.4): import SwiftUI @main struct TestApp: App { var body: some Scene { WindowGroup { NavigationSplitView { Text("sidebar") .toolbar { ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarLeading) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "square.and.arrow.down") } } ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarTrailing) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "square.and.arrow.up") } } } } detail: { Text("detail") .toolbar { ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarLeading) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "eraser") } } ToolbarItem(placement: .topBarTrailing) { Button(action: {}) { Image(systemName: "pencil") } } } } } } } Please check the following GIF for the simple steps, notice how the navbar buttons in the detail view do not disappear: Here's the console output, it shows that the constraints break internally:
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
128
Activity
Apr ’25
White flash using manageSubscriptionsSheet in SwiftUI
In SwiftUI I am using the manageSubscriptionsSheet modifier to open the iOS subscription screen. When this is presented it immediately flashes a white view and then animated the subscription screen up from the bottom, it looks pretty bad. The view I am calling manageSubscriptionsSheet on is presented in a sheet, so maybe trying to present the subscriptions view as well is causing the visual glitch. Any way to not have this white flashing view when opening the subscription screen?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
161
Activity
Oct ’25
Canvas Is Not Updating in Xcode 26
I just updated to Tahoe 26 and Xcode 26, and now a SwiftUI project that was working just fine, simply shows a blank canvas. I closed Xcode and reopened, but get the same results. Note that there is no error message and the project builds and displays normally. Steps to blank canvas: Open Xcode I see Canvas Paused Click on the circle The Form opens with a blank screen Build the project The Form opens with all controls showing Jim
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
183
Activity
Oct ’25